Mark Twain Project Online
Explanatory Notes        Apparatus Notes (Ⓐ)

Source: Springfield (Mass.) Republican, 1881.12.20 ([])

Cue: "If you will"

Source format: "Transcript"

Letter type: "[standard letter]"

Notes:

Last modified:

Revision History: HES

Published on MTPO: 2012

Print Publication:

MTPDocEd
To the Editor of the Springfield (Mass.) Republican
18 December 1881 • Hartford, Conn. (Springfield Republican, 20 December 1881, UCCL 02119)
To the Editor of The Republican:—

If you will glance at the first article in your second editorial column of to-day’s issue you may find two things forcibly illustrated there: that the less a man knows about his subject the more glibly he can reel off his paragraph, &Ⓐemendation that the difference between the ordinary court &Ⓐemendation the high court of journalism is, that the former requires facts, upon which to base an injurious judgment against a man, the other requires suspicions only. You have not caught me in any divergence from the truth, nor in any incompatibility. But a truce to that; under pretext of rising to defend myself, I have really risen for a more respectable purpose. Your remarks have of course disseminated the impression that in my humble person a greater was defeated in Canada &Ⓐemendation got its quietus,—viz., Copyright; now I think the fact is of public &Ⓐemendation general importance—&Ⓐemendation therefore worth printing—that the exact opposite was the case.

I applied formally for Canadian copyrightⒶemendation &Ⓐemendation failed to get it. But this did not cripple my case; because, by being in Canada (&Ⓐemendation submitting to certain legal forms) when my book issued in London, I acquired both imperial &Ⓐemendation Canadian copyrightⒶemendation. I did know, several hours before I left Montreal—as heretofore stated in my name—that my application for local copyright had been refused; but I also knew that my Canadian copyright was perfect without it, &Ⓐemendation that it would not have been (absolutely) perfect if I had not sojourned in Canada while the book was published in England &Ⓐemendation printed &Ⓐemendation published in Canada. Curious as it seems to seem to you, I did leave in Canada perfected arrangements for the prosecution of any who might pirate the book, although I had hardly the ghost of a fear that any attempt would be made to pirate it. Please do not laugh at me any more for this, for the act was not ridiculous. I was not protecting myself against an expectation, but only against a possibility. Perhaps you do not catch the idea. I will put it in another form: If you were going to stop over night with me, I should not expect you to set fire to the place; still, I would step down &Ⓐemendation get the house insured just the same.

Have you ever read the Dominion copyright laws? And if so, do you think you understand them? Undeceive yourself; it is ten thousand to one that you are mistaken. I went to Canada armed to the teeth with both Canadian &Ⓐemendation American legal opinions. They were the result of a couple of months of inquiry &Ⓐemendation correspondence between trained Canadian &Ⓐemendation American lawyers. These man agreed upon but one single thing,—that a perfect imperial &Ⓐemendation provincial copyright was obtainable through a brief sojourn in Canada &Ⓐemendation the observance of certain specified forms.

They were pretty uncertain (under one form of procedure) as to the possibility of acquiring a copyright from the Dominion government itself; well, as before remarked, I tried that form; it failed, but no harm was done. Some little good was done, however; the experiment established the fact, as far as it can be established without the decision of a court, that “elective domicile” is not sufficient in a copyrightⒶemendation matter. There was one other mode of procedure which promised considerably better;—in fact I was told that it had been tried already by a couple of American clergymen, &Ⓐemendation with success. This is, to kind of sort of let on, in a general way, in your written declaration to the Dominion government, that you haven’t come to Canada merely to sojourn, but to stay. My friend, there are reputations that can stand a strain like that; but you know, yourself, that it would not answer for you or me to take any such risk. I declined to try that mode.

Mark Twain.Ⓐemendation

Hartford, Ct., Sunday, December 18, 1881.

Textual Commentary
Source text(s):

Springfield Republican, 20 December 1881, 4.

Previous Publication:

“Mark Twain Explains,” New York Times, 25 December 1881, 3; “Mark Twain Explains,” Publishers’ Weekly, 31 December 1881, 884–85; Roper 1960, 25.

Emendations and Textual Notes
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ copyright ● copy- | right
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ copyright ● copy- | right
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ copyright ● copy- | right
Ⓐ & ● and
Ⓐ Mark Twain. ● Mark Twain.

References

  1. Machlis, Paul, ed. Union Catalog of Clemens Letters. Edited by Paul Machlis. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press. [In some cases, UCCL catalog numbers cited in this volume supersede those assigned in 1986 and reflect corrections or additions to the catalog since publication. An updated version of the catalog can be consulted via the Letters Search page at MTPO.] 1986
  2. Roper, Gordon. “Mark Twain and His Canadian Publishers.” American Book Collector 10 (June): 13–29. 1960
Top