MTPDocEd

[A Call with W. D. Howells on General Grant]apparatus note

Howells

1881explanatory note.apparatus note

Howellsexplanatory note wrote me that his old father, who is well along in the seventies, was in great distress about his poor little consulate, up in Quebec. Somebody not being satisfied with the degree of poverty already conferred upon him byapparatus note a thoughtful and beneficent Providence, was anxious to add to it by acquiring the Quebec consulate. Soapparatus note Howells thought that if we could get General Grant to say a word to President Arthur it might have the effect of stopping this effort to oust old Mr.apparatus note Howells from his position. Therefore, at my suggestion Howells came down and we wentapparatus note to New York to lay the matter before the General. We found him at number 2, Wall street, in the principal office of Grant and Ward, brokers.

I stated the case and asked him if he wouldn’t write a word on a card which Howells could carry to Washington and hand to the President.

But, as usual, General Grant was his naturalapparatus note self—that is to say, ready and also determined to do a great deal more for you than you could possibly have the effrontery to ask him to do. Apparently he never meets anybody half way: he comes nine-tenths of the way himself voluntarily. “No” he said,—he would do better than that and cheerfully: he was going to Washington in a couple of days to dine withapparatus note the President and he would speak to him himself and make it a personal matter.apparatus note Now as General Grant not only never forgets a promise but never evenapparatus note the shadow of a promise,apparatus note he did asapparatus note he said he would do, and within a week came a letter from the Secretary of State, Mr. Frelinghuysenapparatus note, to say that in no case would old Mr. Howells be disturbed. [And he wasn’t. He resigned, a couple of years laterexplanatory note.]apparatus note

[begin page 71]

Grant and Derby

1881.apparatus note

Butapparatus note to go back to the interview with General Grant, he was in a humor to talk—in fact he was always in a humor to talk when no strangers were present—and he resisted all our efforts to leave him.

He forced us to stay and take luncheon in a private room and continued to talk all the time. [It was bacon and beans. Nevertheless, “How he sits and towers”—Howells, quoting from Danteexplanatory note.]apparatus note

He remembered “Squibob” Derby at West Point very well. He said that Derby was foreverapparatus note drawing caricaturesapparatus note of the professors and playing jokes of all kinds on everybody. He also told of one thing, which I had heard before, but which I have never seen in print. At West Point, the professor was instructing and questioning a class concerning certain particulars of a possible siegeapparatus note and he said this, as nearly as I can remember: I cannot quote General Grant’s words:apparatus note

Given: That a thousand men are besieging a fortress whose equipment of men, provisions, etc.apparatus note, are so and so—it is a military axiomapparatus note that at the end of forty-fiveapparatus note days the fort will surrender. Now, young men, if any of you were in command of such a fortress, how wouldapparatus note you proceed?

Derby held up his hand in token that he had an answer for that question. He said: “I would march out, let the enemy in,apparatus note and at the end of forty-fiveapparatus note days I would change places with himexplanatory note.”apparatus note


Grant’s Memoirs

1881.apparatus note

Iapparatus note tried very hard to get General Grant to write his personal memoirs for publication but he would not listen to the suggestion. His inborn diffidence made him shrink from voluntarily coming forward before the public and placing himself underapparatus note criticism as an authorapparatus note. He had no confidence in his ability to write well, whereas Iapparatus note and everybody else in the worldapparatus note excepting himselfapparatus note areapparatus note aware that he possesses an admirable literary gift and style. He was also sure that the book would have no sale and of course that would be a humiliation, too. He instanced the fact that Generalapparatus note Badeau’sapparatus note military history of General Grant had had but a trifling sale,apparatus note and that John Russell Young’s account of General Grant’s trip around the globe had hardly any sale at allexplanatory note. But I said that these were not instances in point;apparatus note that what another man might tell about General Grant was nothing, while what General Grant should tell about himselfapparatus note with his own penapparatus note was a totally different thing. I said that the book would have an enormous sale: that it should be in two volumes soldapparatus note in cashapparatus note at $3 50 apiece,apparatus note and that the sale in two volumes would certainly reach half a million sets. I said thatapparatus note from myapparatus note experienceapparatus note I could save him from making unwise contracts with publishersapparatus note and could also suggest the best plan of publication—the subscription planexplanatory note—and find for him the best men in that line of business.

I had in my mind at that time the American Publishing Company of Hartford, andapparatus note while I suspected that they had been swindling me for ten yearsapparatus note explanatory note I was well aware that I could arrange the contract in such a way that they could not swindle General Grant. But the General said that he had no necessityapparatus note for any addition to his income. I knew that he meant by that that his investmentsapparatus note through the firm in which his sons were partnersapparatus note were paying him all the money [begin page 72] he needed. So I was not able to persuade him to write a book. He said that some day he would make very full notes and leave them behind himapparatus note and thenapparatus note if his children chose to make them into a bookapparatus note that would answer.

Revisions, Variants Adopted or Rejected, and Textual Notes [A Call with W. D. Howells on General Grant]
  [A Call with W. D. Howells on General Grant] ●  not in (TS) 
  Howells | 1881. ●  flush left 1881. centered on the next line Howells.  (TS) 
  by ●  by the  (TS-SLC) 
  consulate. So ●  consulate.— | So (TS) 
  Mr. ●  Mr (TS) 
  went ●  a went (TS-SLC) 
  natural ●  natural blank space left for word on TS  (TS-SLC) 
  with ●  wih | with (TS-SLC) 
  matter. ●  matter . . . (TS) 
  even ●  even  (TS-SLC) 
  promise, ●  promise,  (TS-SLC) 
  as ●  as  (TS-SLC) 
  Frelinghuysen ●  Freyle inghuysen (TS-SLC) 
  [And . . . later.] ● 
And . . . later.
 (TS-SLC) 
  Grant and Derby | 1881. ●  flush left 1881. centered on the next line Grant and Derby.  (TS) 
  But ●  (Howells interview continued) But (TS) 
  [It . . . Dante.] ● 
It . . . Dante.
 (TS-SLC) 
  forever ●  for ever (TS) 
  caricatures ●  caractures (TS) 
  siege ●  siege,  (TS-Redpath) 
  words: ●  words. : period mended to a colon  (TS-SLC) 
  etc. ●  &c. (TS) 
  axiom ●  maxim axiom (TS-SLC) 
  forty-five ●  45 (TS) 
  would ●  w’d | (TS) 
  out, let the enemy in, ●  out, place let the enemy in,  (TS-SLC) 
  forty-five ●  45 (TS) 
  him.” ●  him.  (TS-SLC) 
  Grant’s Memoirs | 1881. ●  flush left 1881. centered on the same line Grant’s Memoirs.  (TS) 
  I ●  (Howell interview continued.) I (TS) 
  under ●  in under  (TS-SLC) 
  author ●  other author  (TS-Redpath) 
  I ●  I,  (TS-Redpath) 
  world ●  world,  (TS-Redpath) 
  himself ●  himself,  (TS-Redpath) 
  are ●  is (TS) 
  General ●  Gen. (TS) 
  Badeau’s ●  Bardou’s Badeau’s  (TS-SLC) 
  sale, ●  sale,  (TS-Redpath) 
  point; ●  point. ; period mended to a semicolon  (TS-Redpath) 
  himself ●  himself,  (TS-Redpath) 
  pen ●  pen,  (TS-Redpath) 
  sold ●  sold,  (TS-Redpath) 
  cash ●  cash,  (TS-Redpath) 
  apiece, ●  a piece,  (TS-Redpath) 
  that ●  that,  (TS-Redpath) 
  my ●  me y  (TS-Redpath) 
  experience ●  experience,  (TS-Redpath) 
  publishers ●  publishers,  (TS-Redpath) 
  and ●  and,  (TS-Redpath) 
  years ●  years,  (TS-Redpath) 
  necessity ●  necessity and no  (TS-Redpath) 
  investments ●  investments,  (TS-Redpath) 
  partners ●  partners,  (TS-Redpath) 
  him ●  him;  (TS-Redpath) 
  then ●  then,  (TS-Redpath) 
  book ●  book,  (TS-Redpath) 
Explanatory Notes [A Call with W. D. Howells on General Grant]
 

1881] The year should be 1882: see the note at 70.19–37.

 

Howells] William Dean Howells (1837–1920) was born at Martin’s Ferry, Ohio, into a large family with radical political and religious tendencies. He was apprenticed to his father, a printer, and became a journalist. With, as he was to say, “an almost entire want of schooling,” he read widely in his father’s library, teaching himself Spanish, German, French, and Italian (Howells to John S. Hart, 2 July 1871, in Howells 1979, 375). In recognition of his support of Lincoln’s 1860 presidential campaign, Howells was rewarded with a consulship in Venice (1861). Returning to America in 1865, he rose as a journalist, moving to Cambridge, Massachusetts, to be assistant editor (1866–71) and then editor (1871–81) of the Atlantic Monthly. In 1881 he retired to concentrate on writing. Among his personal friends were Henry Adams, William and Henry James, and jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. (son of the poet). His friendship with Clemens dates from his review of The Innocents Abroad in 1869 (Howells 1869). Howells used his position at the epicenter of American letters to help assure Mark Twain’s literary success; he also served his friend as editor, proofreader, and sounding-board. In literature, Howells championed and practiced realism. His best novels, out of a vast output, are usually considered to be The Rise of Silas Lapham (1885) and A Hazard of New Fortunes (1890); he memorialized Clemens in My Mark Twain (1910).

 

his old father . . . resigned, a couple of years later] Howells’s father, William Cooper Howells (1807–94), was appointed U.S. consul at Toronto in 1878, after serving for four years as the consul at Quebec. Howells learned in late January 1882 that his father might lose his position, and on 2 March wrote him that he planned “to spend Sunday with Mark Twain who is a great friend of Grant’s, and can possibly get me access to him” (Howells to [begin page 476] William C. Howells, 2 Mar 1882, in Howells 1980, 10–11). Clemens and Howells called on Grant in New York on 10 March. In My Mark Twain, Howells reported that Grant was “very simple and very cordial, and I was instantly the more at home with him, because his voice was the soft, rounded, Ohio River accent to which my years [i.e., ears] were earliest used from my steamboating uncles, my earliest heroes. When I stated my business he merely said, Oh no; that must not be; he would write to Mr. Arthur” (Howells 1910, 71). Grant acted so promptly that Secretary of State Frederick T. Frelinghuysen (1817–85) responded the following day, “You may inform Mr. Clemens that it is not our purpose to make a change in the Consulate at Toronto” (Frelinghuysen to Grant, 11 Mar 1882, CU-MARK). Grant forwarded the letter to Clemens, and he in turn wrote Howells, on 14 March, “This settles the matter—at least for some time to come—& permanently, I imagine. You see the General is a pretty prompt man” (MH-H, in MTHL, 1:394). The elder Howells resigned his post in June 1883 (21 June 1874 to Howells, L6, 166 n. 2; Howells 1979, 61, 196; Howells 1980, 10–11, 14, 58–59).

 

“How he sits and towers” . . . Dante] Howells quoted this phrase in a letter to Clemens from Bethlehem, New Hampshire, of 9 August 1885: “We had a funeral service for Grant, here, yesterday, and all the time while they were pumping song and praise over his great memory, I kept thinking of the day when we lunched on pork and beans with him in New York, and longing to make them feel and see how far above their hymns he was even in such an association. How he ‘sits and towers’ as Dante says” (CU-MARK, in MTHL, 2:536). Less than a month later, on 10 September, Clemens added this quotation to his dictated typescript, inserting in brackets the words “It was bacon and beans” and Howells’s presumed quote from Dante. The phrase is not, however, from Dante, but from a sonnet by Italian dramatist and poet Vittorio Alfieri (1749–1803): “Siena, dal colle ove torreggia e siede” (“Siena, from the hill where she towers and sits”). Howells’s source was E. A. Brigidi’s La Nuova Guida di Siena (a work he drew on for his Tuscan Cities), where it appeared without citation (Brigidi 1885, 11; Howells 1886, 126, 139). Many years later Howells recalled that the “baked beans and coffee were of about the railroad-refreshment quality; but eating them with Grant was like sitting down to baked beans and coffee with Julius Caesar, or Alexander, or some other great Plutarchan captain” (Howells 1910, 72).

 

“Squibob” Derby at West Point . . . would change places with him] Howells later recalled:

Grant seemed to like finding himself in company with two literary men, one of whom at least he could make sure of, and unlike that silent man he was reputed, he talked constantly, and so far as he might he talked literature. At least he talked of John Phoenix, that delightfulest of the early Pacific Slope humorists, whom he had known under his real name of George H. Derby, when they were fellow-cadets at West Point. (Howells 1910, 72)

George Horatio Derby (1823–61), a captain in the U.S. Army Corps of Topographical Engineers, was known primarily for the humorous sketches he wrote under his pseudonym while stationed on the Pacific Coast. These were collected in Phoenixiana; or, Sketches and Burlesques (1856) and, posthumously, The Squibob Papers (1865) (15 Dec 1866 to JLC and family, L1, 374 n. 2).

 

General Badeau’s military history . . . John Russell Young’s account . . . had hardly any sale at all] Adam Badeau (1831–95) became Grant’s military secretary in 1864, and by the time he retired from the army in 1869 (with the brevet rank of brigadier general) the two men had become close friends. President Grant appointed Badeau U.S. consul in London, where he served from 1870 to 1881, except for a leave from his post to travel with Grant for the first five months of his 1877–79 world tour. Between 1868 and 1881 Badeau published his three-volume Military History of Ulysses S. Grant (Badeau 1868–81; N&J3, 107 n. 137; 15 June 1873 to Badeau, L5, 382 n. 1). John Russell Young (1840–99) had a distinguished career as a journalist with several newspapers before becoming managing editor of the New York Tribune from 1866 to 1869. In 1872 he accepted a position as foreign correspondent for the New York Herald. He accompanied Grant on his tour, which he chronicled in Around the World with General Grant (1879). Appointed by President Chester A. Arthur as U.S. minister to China in 1882 (through Grant’s influence), Young mediated a number of disputes involving the United States, China, and France before returning to the Herald in 1885 (14 May 1869 to OLL, L3, 230 n. 6; 17 or 18 June 1873 to Young, L5, 383 n. 1).

 

best plan of publication—the subscription plan] Subscription publishers sold books in advance of publication through agents who went door to door, largely in rural areas, and persuaded people to place orders by showing them a bound “prospectus” with sample pages and illustrations. Subscription books typically cost more than those sold in bookstores, and were the best way to ensure high profits—a lesson that Clemens had learned from his own experience, beginning in 1869 with the American Publishing Company.

 

American Publishing Company . . . swindling me for ten years] In early 1872, shortly after the publication of Roughing It, Clemens began to suspect that his publisher, Elisha P. Bliss, Jr., of the American Publishing Company, was cheating him by overstating his production expenses. He was reassured by Bliss’s explanation, however, and stayed with the firm through the publication of A Tramp Abroad in 1880 (see RI 1993, 877–80; AD, 21 Feb 1906, note at 370.32–33). Although after Bliss’s death in 1880 Clemens considered suing the company, he decided that Francis Bliss, who had succeeded his father, had treated him fairly (26 Oct 1881 to Webster, NPV, in MTBus, 173–74; 28 Dec 1881 to Osgood and Company and 31 Dec 1881 to Osgood, MH-H, in MTLP, 147–49; 3? Oct 1882 to Elliott, CU-MARK; 6 Oct 1882 to Webster, NPV, in MTBus, 203–4). By mid-1883 he was willing to recommend the firm to fellow author George Washington Cable:

If I were going to advise you to issue through a Hartford house, I would say, every time, go to my former publishers, the American Publishing Company, 284 Asylum st. They swindled me out of huge sums of money in the old days, but they do know how to push a book; and besides, I think they are honest people now. I think there was only one thief in the concern, and he is shoveling brimstone now. (4 June 1883 to Cable, LNT)


[A Call with W. D. Howells on General Grant] ❉ Textual Commentary

On the verso of the TS Redpath wrote, ‘Autobiography of Mark Twain | 1 Howells & Grant | 2 Grant & Derby | 3 Grant’s Memoirs.’ There are markings on the TS in pencil; most were made by Redpath, but a few are in Paine’s hand. Clemens reviewed the TS after Redpath, making corrections and revisions in ink.