Gerhardt
1884. (September: at the farm at ElmiraⒺexplanatory note.)Ⓐapparatus note
Gerhardt arrived home from Paris,—leaving his wife and his little boy behind him. He had found living much more expensive at Paris than it had been in J. Q. A. Ward’s day. ConsequentlyⒶapparatus note Ward’s estimate of $3,000Ⓐapparatus note for five years had fallen woefully short. Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note expenses for three years and a half had already amounted to $6,000Ⓐapparatus note. There was nothing for him to do—so he made a bust of meⒶapparatus note in the hope that it might bring him work. The times were very hardⒶapparatus note and he was not able to get anything to doⒺexplanatory note.Ⓐapparatus note
(October.)Ⓐapparatus note
About this time GerhardtⒶapparatus note heard that a competition was about ready to begin for a statue of Nathan Hale, the Revolutionary spy and patriotⒶapparatus note caught and hanged by the British. This statue had been voted by the Connecticut Legislature and the munificent price to be paid for it was $5,000Ⓐapparatus note. The speech which ex-Governor Hubbard had made in advocacy of the proposition was worth four times the sumⒺexplanatory note.
TheⒶapparatus note committee in whose hands the Legislature had placed the matter consisted of Mr.Ⓐapparatus note Coit, a railroad man, of New London,Ⓐapparatus note a modest, sensible, honorable, worthy gentleman, whoⒶapparatus note while wholly unacquainted with art and confessing it,Ⓐapparatus note was willing and anxious to do his duty in the matter. Another committeeman was an innocent ass by the name of Barnard,Ⓐapparatus note who knew nothing about art and in fact about nothing else, and if he had a mind was not able to make it up on any question. As for any sense of duty, that feature was totally lacking in him—he had no notion of it whatever. The third and last committeeman was the reigning Governor of the state, WallerⒺexplanatory note, a smooth-tongued liar and moral coward.
GerhardtⒶapparatus note designed and made a clay Nathan HaleⒶapparatus note and offered it for competition.
A salaried artistⒺexplanatory note of Mr. Batterson, a stone cutter, designed a figure and placed it in competition, and so also did Mr. Woods, an elderly man who was sexton of Mrs. Colt’s private church.
Woods had some talent but no genius and no instruction in art. The stone cutter’sⒶapparatus note man had the experience and the practice that comes from continually repeating the same forms on hideous tombstones—robust prize-fighting angels, mainly.
The figure and pedestal made by GerhardtⒶapparatus note were worthy of a less stingy price than the Legislature had offered,Ⓐapparatus note decenter companionship in the competitionⒶapparatus note andⒶapparatus note a cleaner and less stupid committee.
In the opinion of William C. PrimeⒺexplanatory note and Charles D. WarnerⒺexplanatory note, Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note was a very fine work of art and these men would not have hesitated to awardⒶapparatus note the contract to him. The Governor looked at the three modelsⒶapparatus note and said thatⒶapparatus note as far as he could seeⒶapparatus note Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note was altogether the preferable design. Mr. Coit said the same. But it was found impossible to get the aged BarnardⒶapparatus note to come to look at Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note model. He offeredⒶapparatus note among other excusesⒶapparatus note that he didn’t like to give a statue to a man who still had his reputation to make—that the statue ought to be made by an artist of established reputation. WhenⒶapparatus note asked what artistⒶapparatus note of established reputationⒶapparatus note would make a statue for $5,000Ⓐapparatus note he was not able to reply. It was difficultⒶapparatus note for some timeⒶapparatus note to find out what the real reason was for this old man’s delay, but it finally came out that Mrs. Colt’s money and influence were at the bottom of it. Mrs. Colt was anxious to throw that statue into the hands [begin page 75] of her sextonⒶapparatus note in some way or other. She wrote a letter to the Governor, in which she argued the claims of her sexton, and it presently became quite manifest that the Governor found himself in an uncomfortable position, for the reason that he had characterized the sexton’s attempt as exceedingly poor and crude,Ⓐapparatus note and had also statedⒶapparatus note quite distinctlyⒶapparatus note that of the three models Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note and was ready to vote in that way.
This incredible puppy actually described Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note design to the sexton and advised him to make a new design for competition—which he did;Ⓐapparatus note and he used Gerhardt’sⒶapparatus note design in it! The Governor had no more sense than to tell GerhardtⒶapparatus note that he had done this thing. TakingⒶapparatus note the whole thing roundⒶapparatus note it has been the most comical competition for a statue the country has ever seen. It was soⒶapparatus note ludicrous and soⒶapparatus note paltry—in every way contemptibleⒶapparatus note—that I tried to get GerhardtⒶapparatus note to retire from the competition and make a groupⒶapparatus note for me to be called the Statue Committee to present portraits of these cattle and mousers over a clay image. I said I would write a history of the Nathan Hale committee to go with the statueⒶapparatus note and I believed he could put it in terra cotta and make some money out of it. But he did not wish to degrade his art in gratifying his personal spite and he declined to do it.Ⓐapparatus note
It is customaryⒶapparatus note everywhere else, I believe, for such a committee to specify what is the latest date for the offering of designsⒶapparatus note and also a date when a judgment on them shall be rendered,Ⓐapparatus note but this committee made no limit—at least in writing. Their policy evidently was to give Mrs. Colt’s sexton time enough to get up a satisfactory image—no matter how long that might take—Ⓐapparatus noteand then give him the contract.
Waller failed to be reelected Governor,Ⓐapparatus note but was appointed Consul-General to LondonⒶapparatus note and sailed on the 10thⒶapparatus note of MayⒶapparatus note with the Nathan Hale statue still undecided,Ⓐapparatus note although,Ⓐapparatus note as he had a personal favor to ask of a friend of Gerhardt’s,Ⓐapparatus note just before sailingⒶapparatus note he said “GrantⒶapparatus note me the favor and I will pledge my word that the Nathan Hale business shall be settled before I sail.”Ⓐapparatus note
GerhardtⒶapparatus note kept his clay image wet and waiting three or four monthsⒶapparatus note and then he let it crumble to piecesⒶapparatus note because theⒶapparatus note prospects of the design seemed to be as far away as everⒺexplanatory note.
at the farm at Elmira] From 1871 until 1889, the Clemens family spent their summers at Quarry Farm, the Elmira, New York, residence of Olivia’s sister and brother-in-law, Susan and Theodore Crane. Susy, Clara, and Jean were all born there. The property had been purchased in 1869 by Jervis Langdon, who bequeathed it to his daughter Susan. Named after an old slate quarry on the site, it was situated outside the city, on a hill overlooking the Chemung River. In 1874 Susan built an octagonal study on the hill above the house for Clemens to use as a writer’s retreat. There he worked on The Adventures of Tom Sawyer (1876), A Tramp Abroad (1880), The Prince and the Pauper (1881), Life on the Mississippi (1883), Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1885), and A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court (1889) (17 Mar 1871 to Bliss, L4, 366–67 n. 3; Cotton 1985, 59).
Gerhardt . . . not able to get anything to do] Clemens befriended Karl Gerhardt (1853–1940), a young self-taught sculptor and chief mechanic for a tool manufacturer in Hartford, in February 1881. His wife, Josephine (called “Hattie”), initiated the relationship by calling on Clemens and persuading him to visit her husband’s studio. Clemens, impressed by Gerhardt’s talent, sought the opinions of several artists, who endorsed his judgment: painter James Wells Champney (1843–1903), sculptor John Quincy Adams Ward (1830–1910), and sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens (see AD, 16 Jan 1906, note at 284.7–8). Clemens offered to loan Gerhardt $3,000 to study at the École des Beaux-Arts in Paris, an amount that Ward and others assumed would easily support the artist and his wife for five years. Gerhardt exhausted his stipend (and supplements) in less than four years and returned to the United States in the summer of 1884, leaving his wife in Paris with their infant daughter, Olivia (named in honor of Olivia Clemens; his “little boy,” Lawrence, was not yet born). Having failed to secure any work, he sculpted a clay bust of Clemens, and a plaster casting of it was photographed to provide a second frontispiece for Huckleberry Finn. In the late 1880s Gerhardt won a number of important commissions for memorial statues, but by the end of the decade work became scarce. In the mid-1890s he was briefly in partnership with architect Walter Sanford and was employed by a bicycle manufacturer. Sometime after Hattie died in 1897, he moved to New Orleans and lived in obscurity, doing some sculpting but chiefly tending bar and doing other odd jobs until his own death in 1940 (21 Feb 1881 to Howells [1st], NN-BGC, and 7 Aug 1884 to Howells, MH-H, in MTHL, 1:350–55, 2:497–98; “Art Notes,” New York Times, 6 Mar 1881, 8; letters to the Gerhardts: 30 Sept and 1 Oct 1882, MB; 26 Mar 1883, CLjC; 14–25 June 1883, CU-MARK; 1 Aug 1883, CtHMTH; HF 2003, xxvii, 374; AskART 2008e; see Schmidt 2009c).
The speech . . . was worth four times the sum] Richard D. Hubbard (1818–84) was a Yale graduate and lawyer who served as governor of Connecticut from 1877 to 1879. On 28 March 1883 he addressed the state legislature in Hartford proposing that a statue of Nathan Hale be commissioned for the exterior of the capitol building. A brief sample will explain Clemens’s sarcasm:
Nathan Hale perished more than a century ago, a bloody sacrifice on a bloody altar. . . . In the lonely watches of that prison night whose early dawn was to end his days—yes, in [begin page 481] that night’s thickest gloom and still more in that morning’s horror of great darkness that was to deliver his body from the power of hell, it pleased God—this also I dare affirm—it pleased God to come nigh unto his waiting servant; to uncurtain the future for a space of time, and to let down to his watching eyes a prophetic vision of his country’s coming independence. (“Connecticut’s Martyr Spy,” Hartford Courant, 29 Mar 1883, 1)
The committee . . . Mr. Coit . . . Barnard . . . Waller] Robert Coit (1830–1904), president of the New London Northern Railroad Company since 1881, served as a Connecticut state senator from 1880 to 1883 (“Robert Coit Dead,” Hartford Courant, 20 June 1904, 1; Biographical Review 1898, 276–77). Henry Barnard (1811–1900) was an educator and editor who devoted his career to the improvement of public schools and held a number of government positions. He acquired a reputation, however, as an inept administrator who failed to complete his obligations. He was appointed to the committee to replace Hubbard, who died in February 1884. Thomas M. Waller (1840–1924) practiced law and entered politics in 1867, serving as a state legislator, secretary of state, mayor of New London, and governor from 1883 to 1885.
A salaried artist . . . Mrs. Colt’s private church] The “salaried artist” has not been identified. James G. Batterson (1823–1901), a prominent Hartford businessman and founder of the Travelers Insurance Company, was the president of the New England Granite Works, which specialized in producing “artistic memorials” in granite, marble, and bronze. Enoch S. Woods, a sculptor with a studio in Hartford, was the sexton of the Church of the Good Shepherd. This Episcopal church had been built in 1866 by Elizabeth Jarvis Colt (1826–1905), the widow of Samuel Colt (the founder of Colt’s Patent Fire-Arms Manufacturing Company), as a memorial to her late husband and the three children she had lost in infancy (Geer 1886, 42, 207, 245, 297, 521). Woods created a model of Hale “as he had prepared himself for the hangman’s rope, standing bare-headed and with his hands pinioned” (“A Sculptor’s Model of Nathan Hale,” Hartford Courant, 12 July 1883, 2).
William C. Prime] Clemens had satirized Tent Life in the Holy Land (1857), an idealized travel narrative by journalist and author William C. Prime (1825–1905), in chapters 46 and 48 of The Innocents Abroad—calling him “Grimes”—and in 1908 still considered him a “gushing pietist” (AD, 31 Oct 1908). In late 1885 and early 1886, however, Clemens was negotiating with Prime for the right to publish McClellan’s Own Story, a work that Prime edited on behalf of General George B. McClellan’s widow. The book was issued in 1887 by Webster and Company (31 Jan 1886 to Prime, DLC; N&J3, 218).
Charles D. Warner] Charles Dudley Warner (1829–1900), an essayist, travel writer, and editor of the Hartford Courant, was a central figure in the Hartford Nook Farm community. With Clemens he coauthored The Gilded Age (1873–74), a satirical novel that lent its name to the materialism and political corruption in American society after the Civil War. Warner had met Gerhardt at the same time as Clemens and continued to take an interest in his career (link note following 20–22 Dec 1872 to Twichell, L5, 259–60; 21 Feb 1881 to Howells [1st], NN-BGC, in MTHL, 1:350–55; 5 Apr 1884 to the Gerhardts, CtHMTH).
the prospects . . . seemed to be as far away as ever] In December the committee— [begin page 482] which by then consisted of Coit, Barnard, and Governor Henry B. Harrison (Waller’s successor)—at last awarded the contract to Gerhardt. Olin L. Warner, a sculptor who had studied with the same Paris mentor as Gerhardt (François Jouffroy), persuaded the committee that his sketch was superior to the full-sized model that Woods submitted. A year later Gerhardt’s clay model, a figure of “heroic size . . . standing with his arms partly outstretched,” was approved, and was cast in bronze. Both Clemens and Gerhardt attended the unveiling ceremony in June 1887; the Reverend Joseph Twichell gave the invocation, and Charles Dudley Warner (a new committee member) made the presentation address (Hartford Courant: “The Nathan Hale Statue,” 22 Dec 1885, 2; 22 Dec 1886, 1; “The Hale Statue Unveiled,” 15 June 1887, 5; “The Hale Statue,” 15 June 1887, 1).
Gerhardt ❉ Textual Commentary
On the verso of the TS Redpath wrote, ‘Autobiography of Mark Twain | Gebhart’. There are markings on the TS in pencil; most were made by Redpath, but a few are in Paine’s hand. Paine corrected the spelling of Gerhardt’s name throughout. Clemens made no corrections or revisions.